Friday, February 01, 2008

Banished Equality




By Char D. and Chey K.

The fact that most elementary schools are mostly equal should warm your heart. But our school, Ebert Elementary, has a new rule that has all of us running amuck.



Two fourth grade girls wrote a persuasive essay to our principal, Dr. Howard. Let’s hope they got 100%, because it was pretty persuasive. They wrote that they felt that the girls were being bullied off the field by the boys. They thought it would be fair if the girls could have the field to themselves for one day of the week. Dr. Howard agreed, but took it one step further, she made a boy’s day too. For those who do not know, the girls get the field on Fridays, the boys on Mondays.



Most of the grades are happy that their gender had the field to themselves for a day. All the grades except for 5th. As you may know, most 5th graders play Freeze Tag. But with the new rule, it makes it kind of hard to play because we split the teams into boys and girls. Let’s look into the mind of the 5th grade, shall we? To hear what they have to say about the banished equality.

(BOYS)

Reid G: Girl’s Day (GD) = “It’s totally bogus. Only three days to be together. Such a rip off!”
Boy’s Day (BD) = “Don’t separate genders, it’s totally sexist.”

Mason H: GD= “I hate it. FLAMING ANGER!!!”
BD= “Same.”

Liam K: GD= “Unfair.”
BD= “Same.”


Alex H: GD= “4th grade girls were being too dramatic. We only have three days to play Freeze Tag, it’s way too segregated.”
BD= “A little better, because I’m a boy, but still bad.”

Nate K: GD= “Stinky. I think it’s sexist. Two fourth grade girls can rule over the entire school by writing an essay.”
BD= “Also unfair, but it was only created would feel just against the girls. I don’t think any of this is fair.”

(GIRLS)

Somin K: GD= “It’s so not fair, just because two fourth grade girls weren’t getting along with guys, doesn’t mean everyone has to rush to their aid. Also, the 5th grade can’t play Freeze Tag.”
BD= “Still not fair, wish we didn’t have the stupid rule in the first place.”



Eileen K: GD= “I don’t have any problem with boy’s day; the other girls just need to deal.”
BD= “It’s just not like our school to do this.”

Katie F: GD= “It’s pretty fair. It’s cool the girls can have the field to themselves. But I feel bad for the boys too.”
BD= “Same thing. Keeps balance.”

Mei L: GD= “Kind of stupid. Can’t play Freeze Tag without the boys. Plus, none of the girls are ever actually on the field anyway.”
BD= “It’s sort of balance, but what’s the point if the girls wrote the essay so the girls could have the field. But now they have a day taken away from them. It’s ironic, right?”

Miss Abeyta: “The children should have figured it out for themselves. The boys and girls should have debated and voted for this problem, if there was a problem in the first place.”

So now that you have some idea of what the 5th graders and one of the teachers think, you can decide for yourself if this is banished equality or not.






0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home